Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie Recipe {PB Crave Review}

peanut butter pie recipe

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie Recipe

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie Recipe 

Yes, it tastes as good as it looks. Yes, this Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie Recipe is super simple to make. No, we had no left overs. My most favorite-est ever, ever, ever combo in the whole wide-est world is chocolate and peanut butter. Whether it’s ice cream, candy and now this wonderful, 100% all natural and gluten free peanut butter we so happily discovered, I’m all in! So, here’s  the story behind the peanut butter pie…

This peanut butter pie recipe came about as a review for PB Crave. And, I assumed it would start out like many others. Receive product, give it a go and let ya’ll know what we think. Totally not the case here. See, Ethan has allergies, and can’t eat regular peanut butter and now with my daughter Jessica and the other kiddos here for the summer (and OMG, my family is driving me crazy!) we’ve got the gluten free issue going full force. So, this unassuming package we received with all the delectable flavored peanut butter inside… HUGE hit! Had to make a peanut butter pie! Obviously.

PB Crave sent a jar of each of their four different flavors – Razzle Dazzle, Choco Choco, Cookie Nookie and Coco Bananas. Razzle Dazzle is peanut butter with wild honey, white and dark chocolate and natural raspberry flavor. (Ethan’s absolute favorite!) Cookie Nookie is peanut butter flavored with wild honey, chocolate chips and cookie dough flavor. YES! Cookie Dough! I KNOW!! Coco Bananas is exactly what it says. Real chocolate, and real chunks of bananas! OMGleeee… (this was my favorite. And yes, I ate it right out of the jar with a spoon. Don’t judge) The Choco Choco flavor is definitely for the ultimate of chocolate lovers. It’s a perfect combo of peanut butter, wild honey and sweet and dark chocolate. (grandpa is guarding this jar with his life)

We decided that with so many awesome flavors and choices, we couldn’t just slap it between two pieces of bread and call it good. No, we had to make something awesome. Ready? Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie! Yeah, that totally happened. It was so simple, so delicious and… well… just grab a pen or hit the print button or whatever it is that you do when you see recipes too good to pass up online and get going!


1 (or 2, maybe 4 if you quadruple the recipe?) Pre Made Chocolate Graham Cracker Pie Crusts
1 Cup Peanut Butter (for this, we used the CoCo Bananas, obviously!)
1 Package (8oz) Softened Cream Cheese
1 1/4 Cup Powdered Sugar
1 Tub (8oz) Cool Whip (nope, we didn’t go with ‘Lite’ or reduced fat, flavor anything. Go BIG or go home baby!)


peanut butter pie

Start With 1 Cup Of This!

peanut butter pie

Put in stand mixer with softened cream cheese.
Mix until smooth!

peanut butter pie

Throw in that powdered sugar.
Mix again!

peanut butter pie

Now it’s time for that Cool Whip! Turn the
mixer on full blast and Whip it. Whip it good!
(are you singing too?)

peanut butter pie

This is the beautiful, yummy goodness
you should now have in the bowl.
(go on, stick your finger in there and ‘taste test’)

peanut butter pie

Now, you simply pour the filling into the
ready made crust. Chill for at least an hour.

peanut butter pie

(yes, she made a huge mess,
but just look at that sweet, sticky face!)

(man that sounded almost weird, huh?)



  1. I definitely have to try this one!

  2. These are two of my favorite combos!! Sounds so delicious. But I’d be afraid of eating the whole pie since my husband is allergic to peanuts 🙂

  3. That looks soooo delish! Gotta try this!

  4. This looks easy enough for me to make it! I’ve been looking for an excuse to use my new Kenmore Stand Mixer!

  5. All I can say is YUM! Pinned

  6. This looks so yummy

  7. Sounds yummy, but I think I might be tempted to add chocolate to the peanut butter mixture ;). What do you think? A little melted semisweet chocolate added in?

  8. That does look really good, I am such a plain jane I always only eat apple pie, I never venture off into anything different as far as pies are concerned.

  9. Oh that looks good! Chocolate and peanut butter are such a great pair!

  10. How can you go wrong! Peanut Butter and chocolate! And CoCo Bananas flavor sounds so good!!

  11. Looks so incredibly good, can’t wait for the giveaway!!

  12. You had me at chocolate and PB!! Looks great!

  13. Melanie Schemanski says

    Too bad I don’t have a scratch and lick computer screen!

  14. What a dessert you’ve cooked up Grandma Juice!

  15. Bananas mixed with Peanut Butter?! I must have this

  16. That looks super yummy!!!!!

  17. My mouth is watering right now! I could really go for some of this for a late night snack!

  18. I LOVE chocolate and peanut butter. This looks awesome!

  19. Two of my favorite (peanut butter and chocolate) combined. Wow!

    Hopping from Newbie Blog Hop

  20. Yummy! Thanks for sharing

  21. Dianna Thomas says
  22. Debbie Walter says

    Mmmmm. This looks soooo good! The only thing I would change is that I would use regular graham cracker crusts since I don’t like the chocolate ones. But that’s just my personal preference. Thanks for sharing.

  23. That peanut butter pie looks amazing!

  24. Jennifer Hall says

    Ooooh looks soo plate licking good

  25. It looks so yummy!

  26. This is SO going on my list of things I have to eat… and soon. I’m actually salivating 😀

  27. I can’t believe how simple this way – it didn’t last all the way through dessert!


  1. […] is the original post: Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie Recipe: PB Crave Review Giveaway Tags: butter, butter-chocolate, chocolate, chocolate-lovers, chocolate-peanut, crave, […]

  2. Homepage says:

    … [Trackback]…

    […] Read More: […]…